Tuesday, November 29, 2016

In which we set down the rules for e-ballots at Princeton

This is the message I sent out today. I think it covers everything. I still expect that Friday will be a little crazy, but at the point where the debaters and judges are actually handling e-tournaments like pros, we'll all be better off. 



E-ballots

If you have not already done so, create an account on tabroom.com. Simply click on “sign up” at the top of the page and follow the instructions. Both judges and students should have unique accounts in their own names. 

All judges should come prepared with electronic devices capable of entering results. There is wifi throughout the campus, and any device—smartphone, tablet, computer, Chromebook—will do. Make sure that it is charged, and that it works. E-balloting does not necessarily mean that you need to bring a computer to rounds for flowing or whatnot; the device you decide to use, and how you adjudicate a round, is up to you.

The tournament will not be able to accommodate paper ballots in LD. Judges who are unprepared to judge will be taken out of the tournament, and their schools fined the full hired judging cost for any students left uncovered by the removal.

One half hour before the scheduled start of a round, pairings and assignments will be released, and all participants will be notified of where to go. You will have plenty of time to get there, especially if you use one of the maps that have been provided in the invitation and on tabroom.com. We are using the fewest number of buildings possible, in as close a radius to ground zero (McCosh) as possible.

Judges who have not gotten an assignment shall remain on call in case an assigned judge does not show up. On Friday and on Sunday the rounds are one after the other. On Saturday the rounds are two hours apart. This means that on Saturday you will be enjoying what might be the most leisurely schedule in the Northeast. Take advantage of the breaks, but don’t leave town or go take in an All-Steve-Reeves movie festival.

Given how we are using rooms (alternating novice and varsity on Saturday), combined with a desire to get home before Christmas, we have no choice but to enforce strict rules on making the rounds happen. Everyone is expected to be in the rooms and starting the rounds at the posted times. Judges who are not in their rooms within five minutes of the posted times will be replaced and fined. Students who are not in their rooms within five minutes of the posted times will forfeit. If both students are in the room and there is no judge five minutes after the posted time, students are asked to report missing judges to tab for replacement. Failure to do so will result in double forfeits.

Judges: The only way we can measure what’s happening is by your correct use of the start round button. Please do not hit the start button until you and both of your competitors are in the room and, literally, starting the round. If you press the button willy-nilly before the round starts, it jeopardizes the scheduling of the rooms. If you don’t press the button as the round is starting, we will assume that you are a no-show and replace and fine you.

The phone number of tab is xxx-xxx-xxxx. If there are any problems, text us. What constitutes a problem:
         No judge in room five minutes after start time
         All competitors not in room five minutes after start time

As we say, scheduling of the rooms is tight. We ask judges to limit critiques as much as possible so that we can turn the rooms around in a timely manner. Results will be posted on tabroom as soon as they are all in after each round, and, of course, you can write critiques on your e-ballots, which means that not only will the debaters receive them, but so will their coaches. Judges can add to or modify their comments on e-ballots until the "end of tournament" results are published, which means they can add to them over a cup of coffee during the two hour gaps between rounds on Saturday, although, of course, they cannot change decisions or points.


Thank you. We realize that all of this sounds draconian, to say the least, but for e-ballots to work with this many people in this many buildings requires everyone to be on the same page. The goal is a fair, on-time tournament. Let’s make it so!

No comments: